DIY Homemade Deodorant : My Results

As the title implies, I made homemade deodorant and wanted to document for you just how well it’s been working for me. I know you’ve been waiting for this breakdown, so let me just cut to the chase and say it now: THIS STUFF WORKS! *Celebrate with me* Now that that’s been said, here are my not-so-scientific observations:


I wasn’t sure how much deodorant to put on, so I dabbed a fingertip’s worth for each pit.

Smell Test: Weird. It felt like my musty smell was trying to come through, but the deodorant kept it under control. Unfortunately, I could smell a hint of it every now and again, but this stuff is already way better than the natural deodorant I’ve been using.

HBL Factor: I sometimes ask my husband to sniff my pits to make sure I’m not offending the public (but mostly because I KNOW I stink and I want to see his eyes water). Today, he sniffed and said he could sort of smell me, but it wasn’t as bad as usual.


I thought if I put on more deodorant, it would prevent any hint of odor from coming up like it did yesterday. I REALLY globbed it on today. Mistake. There was so much baking soda/arrowroot powder under my arms, I had to wait for it to dry completely before I could wipe off the excess. And even after that, this still happened:

Homemade Deodorant Use - Final Results 1

The straps on my baby carrier. Yuck

Luckily, it didn’t stain and left no traces after a go ‘round in the wash.

Smell Test: I couldn’t smell as much odor as I did yesterday. Things are looking up.

Itch Factor: It was a little itchy. I wanted to scratch it, but I didn’t because I didn’t want to have to reapply it. Lazy.


I found the perfect amount to apply: I dipped the first digit of my finger into the deodorant, let the excess drip off, then gently dabbed it on. Perfection!

Smell Test: None. I even swiped my finger over my damp-ish underarms and was surprised that there was no smell! Of course, by the late evening, pits were not exactly “fresh”, but definitely not musty smelling.

Itch Factor: A tiny bit, but not enough for me to need to scratch it. Getting excited – I think this actually might be working!


I have not scrutinized my armpits as much as I have in this last week. This is madness.

Smell Test: None. Not even a little bit.

Itch Factor: None


My deodorant separated last night. I decided to try applying just the oil. Afterward, I stirred it up with this handy tool:

Smell Test: Kinda sorta – same results as Day 1. I definitely have to use the entire concoction, not just the oily part.

Itch Factor: None

HBL Factor: HBL finally asked me, “Why are you always smelling your pits?” and I told him because I was reporting back to you all on my new deodorant’s effectiveness. He shrugged his eyebrows at me. And in return, I asked him to smell my underarms again. He stuck his nose into my armpit, took a deep whiff and said: “I don’t smell anything.”




After applying the “perfect” amount of deodorant, I got paranoid and added more.

Smell Test: I got Day 1 results again. Was it because I put on too much deodorant? At the end of the day, when I took off my shirt, my armpits stopped stinking. This can only mean one thing: my poor shirts are probably tainted with must and most likely make me stink worse. Gross. Flipside? SHOPPING!

Itch Factor: None


I was in such a rush to get out the door (I am always in a rush!), I didn’t have time to apply the stuff and wait around for it to absorb. So, I had to use my natural deodorant. I stank so bad, I kept my arms down as much as possible. When I got home, I had to take another shower.

When I finally applied my deodorant, I noticed the mixture was more paste-like! I don’t know if my air conditioner made it cooler in the house so the stuff got to harden up a bit, but I tell you, I really like it in a more solid state! I used almost a pea-sized amount under each arm and I am smell-free once more.

Smell Factor:  None

Itch Factor: None


I am a convert. Unless someone makes this exact recipe commercially, I won’t be buying my deodorant anymore. Granted, I wish this stuff was solid so I wouldn’t have to worry about occasions where I’m really pressed for time, but other than that, I love this stuff.

I still sweat when I wear it, and though I don’t prefer that damp feeling, I do feel confident knowing I don’t smell. It’s such a relief! Go ahead, come in for that random hug, ’cause I know what you’ll smell: NOTHING!

Try it. You’ll like it. It’s good. Go on, make it!

UPDATE 2/19/2014: It’s been well over a year since I last posted about the use of my homemade deodorant, and I have to say it still works! Unfortunately, the baking soda is a bit harsh for me if I use it everyday for two weeks straight – I end up having to take breaks from using it. When I use it too much, my under arms get red, irritated, and sometimes, even get darker. I’ve found that reducing the amount of baking soda and giving my pits a rest on the weekend keeps all of that at bay. I still use this deodorant, but I am definitely on a mission to find the perfect ratio of baking soda to coconut oil. I’ll be back when that happens!

4 thoughts on “DIY Homemade Deodorant : My Results”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge